.
Feedback

Kid Birthday Party Ground Rules

Our kids don't get a party every year. Does this make us the meanest parents ever?

To birthday party or not to birthday party, that is the question.

Neither of my kids will be having a birthday party with their friends this year. Instead, they'll be celebrating their special days with family dinner, cake, presents at home and cupcakes brought to school.

Part of me is filled with relief. The other half feels a little guilty.

After several years of hosting annual birthday parties for our kids and their friends either creatively at home or at interesting locations throughout the area, my husband and I implemented an every-other-year rule for our children. On even numbered birthday years, the kids can help their parents plan a party with their friends to be held at home or at a reasonable party site. On the alternating years, the kids can choose a meal for mom to make or a restaurant for dinner with their immediate family.

It was a policy born partially out of budgetary necessity, since we keep having more children and funnily enough, our children keep making new friends, while still keeping up with their old pals.

Darn them for being so friendly.

It was also a system we thought was important to establish as part of the McFadden Family Anti-Brat Task Force. The theory is if the parties are not a guarantee, on the years they did occur the kids would consider the parties even more special, without Veruca-Salt-like entitlement every year.

But they're only kids once! Before I know it, they'll be teens who might not be the My Super Sweet Sixteen type and will shun the fuss and parental involvement of a big ol' party! Would it be such a big deal to annually invite the kids in the class and the neighborhood over to the house for some games and to beat the heck out of a piñata?

Is it wrong to deprive my kids of an annual party when they loooove them so much?

I know. I know. This dilemma just screams FIRST. WORLD. PROBLEM.

But if you've stayed with me this long, I'm guessing you're in the same middle class parenting bubble. And thus, I'd love to hear what you do at your house!

Do you have a party for your kids every year? Do you save the parties with friends for the years that you believe the kids especially need a little encouragement and fun?

While you ponder those pearl-clutching, hand-wringing, pin-the-tail-on-the-donkey-playing questions, here are some locations in the Wheaton area for children's birthday parties that I recommend:

– Parties for ages 1-12 in which you have the entire gym to yourself, activities geared towards the attendees ages and a special party room for refreshments. Birthday party info here.

Brookside Nature Center – Kids turning 3 years and older can party with a naturalist-led activity, plus refreshments and play. Birthday party info here.

Kensington Volunteer Fire Department  – Give your rescue hero and truck-obsessed kid a party he or she will never forget. My friend and fellow blogger Jodifur  wrote a great guest post on my blog here on her experience hosting her son's birthday party at this fire station.

- The Train and Carousel will reopen weekends in April and you can host your spring, summer or fall b-day party in one of their two event rooms.  Birthday party info here.

Cutie Patootie Birthdays and Such – This new, pinkalicious girly tea party location on the Silver Spring/Olney border on Georgia Avenue is cute as pie.

Looking for more birthday party locations? Check out my list here.

Jessica McFadden is a mom of two with one more on the way who writes at A Parent in Silver Spring and elsewhere...when not obsessing over kid party privileges and other extremely serious parenting issues.

Dawn Mooney February 23, 2011 at 12:31 am
Nope, no party every year for us, either. We haven't made a hard-and-fast even/odd year rule, but "big" years have gotten parties- 1, 3, 5, 10. Hey, we're certainly not harming them psychologically when they're still getting a special dinner, yummy cake and gifts!
I love your tone here, Jessica!
Amy Mascott February 23, 2011 at 12:39 am
Love the idea of no party every year, Jessica! Seriously--no reason for it in my mind. The problem is that we were so excited with our first, we partied for her every year up to 7 (sure, the first few were 'our' friend parties that we tied into her birthday, but still. . . . Now we're trying to make things right by toning down big time without totally cheaping out on kiddos #2 and 3.
Becky February 23, 2011 at 01:44 am
We do the party scene every year - never really considered not. However, the first birthday was always a big one at home with lots of family and kids. After that, we had parties at other locations but generally kept it at about 15 - which included aunts, uncles and grandparents. Son number 1 did have a few bigger ones until his brothers came along. We find a place that does all the work for a set price - clean up and all. We stick to whatever number that includes. The boys never ask for much and are as far from the "brathood" as you can get. Matter a fact, there have been times we've insisted no presents or did a food drive for a local pantry. They are accepting of hand-me-down clothes, bikes, and all kinds of stuff - they think that is great. So I don't feel so bad splurging just a little for a party each year. They get so excited, I just can't say no. We do have a low key quiet family party on the actual birthday of each person and some traditions that go with it.
jodifur February 23, 2011 at 03:02 am
Hey, thanks for the shout out! Now that I'm planning Michael's 6th party, and nothing can compare to last year's fire house blast I think every other year would be a great idea.
Lisa February 23, 2011 at 03:41 pm
This article is spot on! Of course the first birthdays were big and we were blessed with both children being born in the same month so we had fun with some big organized combo birthday parties over the years, but with the four year age gap the combo's don't fit so easily as their tastes and interests differ more with age. They know that their parents walked to school in the snow with no shoes on :-). So they'll appreciate a big organized birthday party when it fits the budget for that particular year. Otherwise, they have an immediate family celebration of their choice i.e. restaurant, local tourist attraction, local amusement park (and take a friend), day trip and of course good ole' sleepovers! Thanks for the article.
Kristen Walker Painemilla February 23, 2011 at 04:15 pm
Good article! I think it's a good approach moving it to every other year. I have two kids with birthdays in August and was recently contemplating how to manage the birthdays! I think every other year is a great plan!
I also really like the family dinner birthday with cake! It brings back my own childhood memories!
Leslie February 23, 2011 at 05:32 pm
We've always had a "friends" party separate from the family party. It's a bit exhausting because our two girls' birthdays are 2 weeks apart in Februrary, but we've kept things sane by having a rule that the girls can only invite as many friends as the age they are turning. So, my soon-to-be 7 year old has invited 7 school friends. We usually do a party at home, which is more work and prep, but just as much fun and MUCH cheaper than a party at the many fabulous party venues in the area.
Lisa G February 23, 2011 at 08:00 pm
I can't imagine skipping a birthday party. Toning down, sure, since it sounds like things have gotten out of hand for you, but skipping it altogether? Seems drastic to me. Who says you have to go crazy and spend a ton of money? Cake + candles + balloons = party, in my mind.
Since your kids are old enough to help plan, I imagine they can handle the concept of choosing between cake and ice cream for 15 friends or something more fabulous for 4 close friends. Like Leslie, we also did the age = number of guests things to growing up, so I still follow that now. For presents, we have card and crafty things and ask guests to make a card with one thing they like about Birthday Girl. She pre-writes hers for her guests before the party and decorates them along with everyone else. It's the main activity. They all love it. I love not having a bunch of new toys to deal with.
{sue @ laundry for six} February 24, 2011 at 03:40 pm
I completely agree. There's no way we can have a party every year with four kids. Even a cheap party at home ends up being more than $100. Our best idea ever was to rent a moon bounce for the day and have 3 back to back birthday parties. I was exhausted by the end, but it was cost effective. (It also obviously wasn't on everyone's birthday, but it was close enough to 3 of them that we made it work.)
Jessica McFadden February 26, 2011 at 12:27 pm
Ohhhh, great idea! I'm envisioning a big January or February bday party next year - the months between Charlie and Eve's big days. Project!
Janel February 28, 2011 at 05:08 pm
We have been fairly lax on the bday parties mostly because we are really bad at planning anything! So I guess we could say that we are doing every other year until the kids notice :)

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Wheaton Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Susan S. Berkheimer June 5, 2013 at 05:40 pm
Thanks for the memories of our favorite park, Hershey Park in Hershey, PA. The old wooden rollerRead More coaster was also our very favorite.There was also another favorite, much tamer Love Boat ride that went through a dark tunnel and then went up an incline and you got wet at the end of the ride. Visiting the Hershey Chocolate Factory was also a must on our trip to Hershey. We grew up in nearby York, PA.
Jean Winegardner June 5, 2013 at 05:54 pm
Oooh, that Love Boat ride sounds really fun! We didn't see that one. We definitely had quite anRead More experience there!
Susan S. Berkheimer June 5, 2013 at 06:09 pm
Going to Hershey Park had been a yearly event when we took our own three children to Hershey Park.Read More They loved it there,too. All three of our children are now married and have taken their children to Hershey Park. We have also been to Hershey, PA to the famous Hershey Car Show, where we purchased a 1994 Chrysler LeBaron convertible. I enjoyed reading your article.
Jean Winegardner May 23, 2013 at 01:35 am
Cori, you have no idea how much this helps. I just found out some of the details about the Geo BowlRead More and it sounds like a much better situation for my kiddo than I was originally imagining. I'm going to reach out to the team tonight. I imagine that they will be receptive to my worries. I'm hoping that all of the worst case scenarios are in my head and only in my head, which is probably likely. :) Maybe I'll see you at the Geo Bowl!
vero May 23, 2013 at 02:57 pm
Priming is key. You can also show him video on similar bowls. Pretend at home with family afterRead More finding out more or less how it will go the day of event. Encourage and prime/prep. How wonderful that he has come so far!
Jean Winegardner May 25, 2013 at 02:26 am
Great tips! And actually, thank you very much for the reminder that he has come really far. You'reRead More so right. And I'm so proud of him!
Catherine Newnham May 15, 2013 at 04:44 pm
Yes and yes to everything you say here. The reality of parenthood is simultaneously far far worseRead More and far far better than the fantasy could possibly be. The truth about living with multiple pairs of giant stinky man shoes should be enough to make most of us think twice about filling our houses with male offspring. And when did I sign up to help a hormonal 15 yr old write an impossible essay on a book he's not yet read, due in 3 days? It's lucky we love them so much is all I can say.